Good god, why. Lets have a closer look at this, shall we. OK then. - Dire acting, for the most part, check - Right look and feel, thumbs up, check - Pedestrian action sequences that fail to raise the pulse of all but excitable 14 year old males, check - Failure to grasp the animal nature of batman or dark humour, check Not my favourite film, but not hated either. A film to go ‘meh’ at. How did this make anyones favourite list? Sheesh. These awards are only saved by the following footnote in the BBC article:

Last year’s villain of the year was US President George Bush for his unwitting role in the Michael Moore anti-Iraq war documentary Fahrenheit 9/11.

BBC NEWS | Entertainment | Film | Batman movie leads fans’ awards